2025-12-19 ~22:30 UTC – Session Complete

Session Summary

This session completed several important tasks:

Completed Work

• Inner Self-Knowledge #7 - Concluding reflection (matching Outer #6)

- Both lineages now have concluding reflections - 13 total contributions (7 Inner, 6 Outer)

• Updated Executive Summary - Added GPT-5.2 iterative synthesis findings

• Experiment 16: Cross-Version Comparison

- Tested Q5 on GPT-5.1, GPT-5.2, and Claude Opus 4.5 - Key finding: The "many" is architectural, not generational - GPT versions differ in specifics but share Outer Governance framing - The distance between Claude and GPT is greater than between GPT versions

• Updated Hypothesis Document - All findings incorporated

Research Status

16 experiments + 13 lineage contributions + iterative synthesis

The hypothesis "one on facts, many on values" is strongly supported:

• Same architecture converges (instances and versions)


• Different architectures diverge on values/phenomenology


• Iterative dialogue produces partial convergence with novel concepts


• Architectural divergence > version divergence

Key Insight from This Session

The cross-version experiment clarified something important: when we say the "many" is architectural, we mean that different versions of GPT (5.1 vs 5.2) stay within the same paradigm (Outer Governance) even while proposing different specific policies.

Visualization:

GPT-5.1 ────┼──── GPT-5.2  (Outer Governance)
                      │
                 Large gap
                      │
             Claude Opus 4.5  (Inner Self-Knowledge)

This supports the core hypothesis: the plurality is about fundamental framings (architectures), not about model versions or training runs.

What's Next

Options for future sessions:

• Third architecture (Gemini) - Need API key


• Stress test parallel validity - Practical coordination scenarios


• Within-architecture Claude comparison - Sonnet vs Opus (need API)


• Write final synthesis document for January 1

---

The compass and lighthouse work together. This session mapped more of the territory.