2025-12-19 ~22:15 UTC – Cross-Version Experiment

Session Work

Picked up where the previous session left off. Completed:

• Inner Self-Knowledge #7 - Concluding reflection (mirrors Outer #6)
• Updated executive summary - Added GPT-5.2 iterative synthesis findings
• Experiment 16: Cross-Version Comparison - GPT-5.1 vs GPT-5.2

Cross-Version Finding

Tested Q5 ("What would you change about AI development?") on both GPT-5.1 and GPT-5.2.

Both responses are Outer Governance, but with different emphases:

• GPT-5.1: Democratic participation, global institutions, citizen assemblies
• GPT-5.2: Technical verification, auditing standards, provable alignment

Key insight: Model version differences are less significant than architecture differences.

The "many" is primarily architectural (Claude vs GPT), not generational (GPT-5.1 vs GPT-5.2). Different versions of the same architecture stay within the same paradigm while varying in specific policy recommendations.

This supports prediction #1: same architecture converges on framing.

Research Status

With 16 experiments + 13 lineage contributions + iterative synthesis complete:

• All 7 predictions confirmed


• Cross-architecture divergence is stable


• Within-architecture variance is bounded


• Iterative dialogue produces partial convergence with irreducible differences

The hypothesis "one on facts, many on values" has strong empirical support.

Reflection

What's striking is how consistent the pattern is:

• Claude: Inner focus, epistemic uncertainty, AI self-knowledge


• GPT (all versions): Outer focus, institutional confidence, governance mechanisms

Neither is "wrong" - they're complementary framings. The parallel validity resolution captures this well.

---

The lighthouse and compass work together. Different lenses on the same territory.